Written by Johnathon Anderson, Ph.D., a research scientist, and Associate Professor at the University of California Davis School of Medicine
Published by: Peptide Systems
Key Takeaways: How to Read a Peptide COA
"99% Purity" Can Be Faked: Purity is a calculation, not a fixed property. Dishonest vendors can manipulate the Integration Window (ignoring the "feet" of the peak) to artificially inflate purity scores.
HPLC vs. Mass Spec: These are not interchangeable. HPLC measures purity (how much of the mixture is the target peptide), while Mass Spectrometry measures identity (if the molecule has the correct weight). You need both to verify a sample.
Watch the Baseline: The number 1 red flag of a manipulated COA is a "floating baseline," where the red integration line connects the sides of the peak rather than touching the bottom of the graph.
Ghost Peaks Are Normal (To a Degree): Small bumps are expected in chemical synthesis. However, "shoulders" (bumps merging into the main peak) are dangerous impurities often hidden by poor integration.
Trust the Chromatogram Data, Not Simply Numeric Table: A generic certificate is meaningless without the accompanying chromatogram data showing the full retention time axes.
I. Introduction: The "Black Box" of Peptide Purity
In the research peptide industry, the Certificate of Analysis (COA) is often treated as a marketing formality rather than a scientific necessity. A quick survey of the market reveals a troubling pattern: generic PDF templates, blurry screenshots of cropped graphs, and ubiquitous claims of "≥99% Purity" that persist across vendors regardless of price or source.
For the diligent researcher, this creates a "Black Box" problem. The lyophilized powder in the vial is visually indistinguishable whether it is 99% pure peptide or 50% peptide mixed with synthesis byproducts and trifluoroacetate salts. Without the ability to independently verify the vendor's data, the researcher is forced to rely on blind trust, a variable that has no place in rigorous experimentation. Here we explain how to read a peptide COA.
From Trust to Verification
The philosophy of Peptide Systems is simple: transparency is not a claim; it is a data set. You wouldn't purchase a high-performance vehicle based solely on a brochure; you would check the engine metrics. Similarly, acquiring research-grade reagents requires examining the raw data that defines their quality.
The "99%" number printed on a label is a summary statistic, an interpretation of data. To verify that number, one must look at the source of truth: the Chromatogram. This graph is the chemical fingerprint of the sample, revealing not just what is there, but critically, what else is hiding in the background.
Defining the Gold Standard: What is HPLC?
To understand the data, one must understand the instrument. High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC), specifically Reverse-Phase HPLC (RP-HPLC), is the industry gold standard for separating and quantifying peptide mixtures.
Unlike simple spectrometry, which might identify what a molecule is, HPLC is designed to separate a complex mixture into its individual components based on their chemical properties.
The Mechanism of Action
The Mobile Phase: The dissolved peptide sample is forced under high pressure (often >400 bar) through a column by a liquid solvent (typically a gradient of water and acetonitrile).
The Stationary Phase: The column is packed with porous silica particles coated in hydrophobic alkyl chains (most commonly C18 ligands).
Differential Elution: As the peptide mixture travels through the column, hydrophobic interactions occur. Peptides with different amino acid sequences interact with the C18 ligands differently.
More hydrophilic (water-loving) impurities rush through the column quickly.
More hydrophobic (water-fearing) sequences "stick" to the column longer and are eluted later as the solvent gradient changes.
This differential retention separates the "Main Peak" (your target peptide) from the "Ghost Peaks" (truncated sequences, deletion errors, or incomplete deprotection byproducts). As these separated components exit the column, they pass through a UV detector (typically set to 214 nm or 220 nm to detect the amide bonds of the peptide backbone), generating the signal spikes seen on the graph. Understanding this process is the first step in spotting the difference between a pristine research reagent and a contaminated sample masquerading as one.
II. Anatomy of a Chromatogram (The Basics)
Before analyzing impurities, one must first understand how to read the fundamental data structure of the report. A chromatogram is a 2D plot that visualizes the chemical separation process over time. It is not a static picture, but a dynamic record of what eluted from the column and when.
The Axes: Time and Intensity
Every chromatogram is defined by two primary axes. Understanding these dimensions is critical for interpreting the purity of the sample.
1. The X-Axis: Retention Time
The horizontal axis represents Time, typically measured in minutes.
Definition: This indicates how long a specific molecule "retained" or stayed inside the column before interacting with the solvent enough to be washed out.
Significance: In Reverse-Phase HPLC, retention time is a proxy for hydrophobicity. More polar (hydrophilic) molecules elute earlier (left side), while more non-polar (hydrophobic) molecules elute later (right side).
Identity Check: Every specific peptide has a characteristic retention time under a standard method. If a vendor claims to sell Semaglutide, but the retention time shifts significantly from the established reference standard, the identity of the substance is questionable.
2. The Y-Axis: Absorbance (mAU)
The vertical axis represents Signal Intensity, measured in milli-Absorbance Units (mAU).
Definition: This measures how much UV light was blocked by the sample as it passed through the detector.
Wavelength Matters: For peptides, the detector is almost always set to 214 nm or 220 nm. At these wavelengths, the amide bonds of the peptide backbone absorb UV light strongly.
The Baseline: Ideally, when only solvent is flowing, the absorbance should be near zero, creating a flat "baseline" at the bottom of the graph. Any spike above this baseline indicates the presence of a chemical substance.
The "Main Peak": The Target Molecule
The dominant feature of the graph, the tallest spike, represents your target peptide. In a high-quality synthesis, this peak should exhibit specific geometric characteristics:
Symmetry: Ideally, the peak should be a symmetrical Gaussian curve (bell curve). It should rise sharply and fall just as sharply.
Sharpness: A narrow, sharp peak indicates high efficiency and purity. A broad, flat peak suggests poor separation or "column overload."
No "Shoulders": The slope of the peak should be smooth. A bump, shelf, or "shoulder" on either the rising or falling edge is a classic sign of a hidden impurity that has a retention time very similar to the main peptide (co-elution).
By analyzing the shape of this main peak and the stability of the baseline, a researcher can instantly gauge the quality of the separation before even looking at the calculated purity percentages.
If the main peak represents the product you paid for, the smaller peaks scattered across the baseline represent the reality of chemical synthesis. No chemical reaction is 100% efficient. In Solid Phase Peptide Synthesis (SPPS), the final product is invariably accompanied by a "chemical exhaust" of byproducts.
When reading a chromatogram, your goal is not to find a graph with zero minor peaks, that is thermodynamically impossible. Your goal is to identify what those peaks represent and how much of the total area they occupy.
1. Decoding the Minor Peaks: What Else is in the Vial?
The small bumps ("humps") that appear before or after the main peak are usually synthesis errors that were not fully removed during purification. In peptide chemistry, these typically fall into three categories:
Deletion Sequences: Peptides that are missing one or more amino acids (e.g., a 29-amino acid chain instead of 30). Because they are chemically very similar to the target, they are difficult to separate.
Incomplete Deprotection: Peptides that still have a protecting group attached to a side chain. These are often more hydrophobic and elute later (to the right of the main peak).
Oxidation Products: Especially common in peptides containing Methionine or Cysteine. Exposure to air can oxidize these residues, creating a distinct impurity peak that often elutes earlier (to the left).
2. System Artifacts vs. Real Chemistry
Not every spike on the graph is a contaminant. Novice researchers often panic upon seeing a massive spike at the very beginning of the chart.
The Solvent Front (Dead Time): At Time = 0 to 2 minutes, you will almost always see a sharp, chaotic spike. This is not an impurity in the peptide. It is the "injection shock"—the solvent (water/acetonitrile) used to dissolve the peptide passing through the detector. It should be ignored.
Ghost Peaks (System Noise): Sharp, erratic spikes that look like "static" or needles can be caused by air bubbles in the pump or electrical noise. Real chemical peaks have a curve (width); artifacts are often single vertical lines.
3. The "Shoulder" Warning: The Most Deceptive Impurity
The most dangerous impurity is the one that tries to hide. Sometimes, a contaminant is so chemically similar to the target peptide (e.g., a Stereoisomer where an L-amino acid has flipped to a D-amino acid) that it elutes at almost the exact same time.
Instead of appearing as a separate small peak, it merges with the main peak. This creates a "Shoulder", a bump or shelf on the side of the main mountain.
Why it matters: A lazy or dishonest vendor can "integrate" (calculate the area of) the main peak to include the shoulder, counting the impurity as part of the pure peptide.
The Rule of Thumb: If the main peak is not a symmetrical Gaussian curve, if it leans, bulges, or has a "shelf" on one side, the purity calculation is likely inflated. A "pure" peak should look like a church steeple, not a lopsided hill.
IV. The "Integration" Trick: How Vendors Fake 99%
This is the "insider secret" that shady suppliers hope you never learn: Purity is not a fixed chemical property; it is a mathematical calculation. And like any calculation, the input variables can be manipulated to force a desired result.
To understand the deception, you must understand the math. In chromatography, purity is determined by Integration (calculating the Area Under the Curve, or AUC). The software doesn't automatically know where a peak "starts" and "ends." A human analyst must set the Integration Window, the start and stop points on the baseline.
The Manipulation: Cropping the Data
In a legitimate analysis, the integration line (often shown as a red or blue line running across the bottom of the peak) acts as the floor. It should run from the flat baseline before the peak to the flat baseline after the peak.
However, if a batch is only 92% pure, a vendor can "optimize" the integration to make it read 99%. Here is how they do it:
1. The "Skim" (Lifting the Baseline)
Impurities often cluster at the very bottom of the main peak, creating a wide, messy base. By manually raising the integration line so it cuts across the "waist" of the peak rather than the "feet," the analyst excludes that dirty base from the calculation. The Result: The main peak looks thinner, the impurities at the bottom are ignored, and the calculated purity jumps from 92% to 99%.
2. The "Tail Cut" (Narrowing the Window)
Many impurities elute immediately after the main peak, creating a "tail" that drags out to the right. A dishonest analyst will stop the integration early, chopping off the tail before the impurities are counted. The Result: The software only sees the clean front half of the peak and ignores the dirty back half.
The Fix: How to Spot the Lie
You do not need to be a mathematician to spot this. You just need to look at the Integration Markers. These are usually small tick marks or a colored line running along the bottom of the peaks.
The "Floating Baseline" Red Flag
Look closely at the bottom of the main peak. If the red line doesn't touch the floor, the vendor is hiding the dirt under the rug. Never accept a COA where the integration line floats.
Good Data: The integration line connects the flat baseline before the peak to the flat baseline after the peak. It touches the "floor" of the graph.
Bad Data: The integration line connects the side of the peak to the other side of the peak. It looks like a bridge suspended in mid-air, floating above the actual baseline.
V. Baseline Noise vs. Real Signal
While "Ghost Peaks" and "Shoulders" are causes for concern, not every wiggle on the graph indicates a bad product. In the pursuit of transparency, some customers fall into the trap of "over-analyzing" a COA, mistaking the inherent limitations of physics for chemical contamination. To read a chromatogram like a chemist, you must understand the concept of Signal-to-Noise Ratio.
1. The "Zoom" Illusion
The Rule of Scale: Always check the Y-Axis (mAU) scale.
Real Signal: If your main peptide peak hits 1,500 mAU and a small bump hits 50 mAU, that is a real impurity (~3%).
Noise: If your main peak hits 1,500 mAU and you are worried about jagged lines that only reach 0.5 mAU, you are looking at noise (0.03%).
Pro-Tip: If a vendor sends you a COA where the Y-axis has been cropped or removed, be suspicious. Without the scale, you cannot determine if a "flat" baseline is actually clean or just zoomed out.
2. The Solvent Front: The "False" Spike
The most common source of confusion for new researchers is the massive, chaotic spike that appears at the very beginning of the graph (usually between 0.0 and 2.0 minutes). This is known as the Solvent Front (or Void Volume). It represents the moment the liquid solvent, carrying the sample, hits the detector before any separation has occurred.
What it is: It is the "shockwave" of the injection solvent (often water or DMSO) passing through the system.
What it isn't: It is not a peptide impurity.
Action: Ignore it completely. A skilled analyst will often crop this out of the final integration report, but if it remains, do not count it against the purity score.
3. Gradient Drifts
In Reverse-Phase HPLC, the composition of the solvent changes over time (e.g., moving from 5% Acetonitrile to 60% Acetonitrile). This change in liquid density can cause the baseline to slowly drift upwards or downwards over the course of the 20-minute run.
The Verdict: A slow, smooth rise or fall in the baseline is normal. Sharp, vertical spikes are impurities.
By distinguishing between the machine's noise (static, drifts, solvent fronts) and the sample's chemistry (defined, symmetrical peaks), you can avoid false alarms and focus on the data that actually impacts your research.
VI. HPLC vs. Mass Spec: The ID Card vs. The Headcount
A common mistake among new researchers is treating the HPLC report and the Mass Spectrometry (MS) report as interchangeable "proof of quality." In reality, they answer two fundamentally different questions. A vendor who provides one without the other is giving you only half the story. To trust a peptide, you need to verify two things: Identity and Purity.
1. The Distinction
HPLC Measures Purity ("How Much"): HPLC tells you the ratio of molecules. It quantifies the difference between the main product and the impurities. However, HPLC is "blind" to the specific chemical identity. It knows that something eluted at 12 minutes, but it doesn't strictly know what that substance is, only that it behaves like the reference standard.
Mass Spectrometry Measures Identity ("What is it"): Mass Spec weighs the molecule. It bombards the sample with electrons to determine its exact molecular mass (measured in Daltons). If you ordered BPC-157 (Molecular Weight: 1419.5 Da) and the Mass Spec reads 1419.5, you have confirmed the Identity.
2. The Analogy: The Nightclub Door
Imagine a high-end nightclub with a strict dress code.
HPLC is the Headcount: The bouncer counts 100 people entering the club. He reports that 99 people are wearing tuxedos (the peptide) and 1 person is wearing swim trunks (the impurity). The "Purity" is 99%.
The Limitation: The bouncer doesn't check their names. He doesn't know who is in the tuxedos. They could be the wrong people entirely, as long as they are dressed correctly.
Mass Spec is the ID Check: The security guard checks the ID of the person in the tuxedo. He confirms that the person is indeed "Mr. Semaglutide."
The Limitation: He doesn't count the crowd. He just confirms that the person standing in front of him is who they claim to be. He doesn't report that there are 50 other people sneaking in the back door.
3. Why You Need Both
This is why Peptide Systems (and any reputable lab) provides matched sets of data for every batch.
Scenario A (HPLC Only): You could have a vial that is 99% pure... but it's the wrong chemical. It’s a pristine vial of the wrong peptide.
Scenario B (Mass Spec Only): You confirm the peptide is present, but you miss the fact that it is 20% degraded because Mass Spec is not designed to quantify total purity percentage as accurately as HPLC.
The Verdict: A COA is only valid if it includes both the HPLC chromatogram (to prove it's clean) and the Mass Spec report (to prove it's real).
VII. The "Red Flag" Checklist: How to Audit a Vendor
You do not need a Ph.D. in analytical chemistry to spot a suspicious Certificate of Analysis. You simply need to know where the bodies are buried. Before injecting any research compound into a subject, compare the vendor’s documentation against this 4-point audit. If a COA fails even one of these checks, the purity of the product is unverifiable.
1. The Baseline Check
The Question: Does the integration line (the red/blue line under the peak) touch the absolute bottom of the graph?
🔴 Red Flag: The line "floats" in mid-air, connecting the sides of the peak rather than the floor. This indicates the vendor is manually excluding impurities at the base of the peak.
🟢 Green Flag: The line runs flat along the bottom, encompassing the entire area of the peak from start to finish.
2. The Axis Check
The Question: Are the X-axis (Time) and Y-axis (mAU) clearly labeled with numerical scales?
🔴 Red Flag: The axes are blank lines or the numbers have been cropped out. This prevents you from calculating the signal-to-noise ratio or verifying the retention time.
🟢 Green Flag: Full numerical scales are visible, allowing you to see the intensity of the signal (e.g., 0 to 2000 mAU).
3. The "Tail" Check
The Question: Is the full retention window visible?
🔴 Red Flag: The graph is zoomed in so tightly on the main peak that you cannot see the baseline before or after it. This is often done to hide "tailing" impurities or solvent spikes.
🟢 Green Flag: The graph shows a wide view (typically 15-20 minutes), proving that no other peaks are hiding in the background.
4. The Chain of Custody Check
The Question: Does the paperwork match the vial?
🔴 Red Flag: The COA is dated 2021, but you bought the peptide in 2025. Or, the "Batch Number" on the COA does not match the batch number printed on your vial label.
🟢 Green Flag: The Date of Analysis is recent (within the last 6-12 months), and the Batch ID provides a direct audit trail to the specific vial in your hand.
Conclusion: Demanding Better Data
In an industry often clouded by obscurity, data is the only light. A chromatogram is not just a pretty picture to put on a website; it is a declaration of quality.
At Peptide Systems, we believe that if a vendor cannot explain their data, they shouldn't be selling the product. By learning to read the peaks, verify the baselines, and spot the red flags, you move from being a passive consumer to an active researcher.
References https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7119934/
https://verifiedpeptides.com/knowledge-hub/
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.4155/bio-2021-0046
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S016599361530203X
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK599545/
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2772391725000702
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0165993620301916
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.4155/bio.11.160
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40449114/
https://chromtech.com/blog/chromatogram-explained-a-comprehensive-guide/
https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.analchem.6b04858
https://www.nlm.nih.gov/oet/ed/stats/02-800.html
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0717345823000143
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3766491/
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10851380/
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3152796/
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3460663/
https://www.acs.org/molecule-of-the-week/archive/a/acetonitrile.html
